Emergency preparedness
Flooding and abandon-ship drills on small commercial vessels: from 'written down' to 'practised'
A flooding or abandon-ship drill only helps if it covers the real decisions and actions the crew will face, like finding the water, closing openings, starting pumps, calling for help early, and getting passengers into lifejackets and off the boat. Most small operators have these steps written down, but not many have actually practised, timed or improved them after a drill went wrong. The MAIB's latest safety flyer sums it up: make sure your vessel operations are both approved and practised.
This guide explains what the rules require, how to set up drills that test your crew's real response on a small vessel, and how to record them so you can keep improving.
Why a written procedure isn't enough
In September 2026, the MAIB released its report on the sinking of the fishing vessel Argos Georgia, where 13 people lost their lives. It also published a safety flyer called "Are your vessel operations approved and practised?" Although Argos Georgia was a fishing boat, not a ferry or workboat, the lessons from the flyer apply to all small operators:
- Risk-assess how the vessel is actually operated, not how the paperwork says it is. Weathertight doors were routinely left open, against the stability booklet.
- Drill for flooding. "Practising closing watertight flaps and ventilation dampers can buy time."
- Never hesitate to send a Mayday. Informal distress messages sent by WhatsApp delayed search and rescue by about two hours.
The report found that the crew's emergency response was unstructured, and both the distress call and abandoning ship were delayed. The company did not have systems in place for flooding, abandonment or distress emergencies.
This same problem happens on smaller boats too. There might be a written procedure, but if no one has practised the first ten minutes, the important decisions (calling for help, closing up, getting people into lifejackets) are made too late.
What the rules require
Drill rules depend on your vessel's class and code, so check the one that applies to you.
- Domestic passenger ships under the DSM Code (MGN 536 and MSIS 29). Your SMS sets out drill procedures tailored to how the vessel operates, and in practice core drills (fire, flooding, abandon ship) are run at least monthly. MCA surveyors witness a drill on board at audit, and drill records are kept in a training manual.
- Ships covered by the Musters, Training and Decision Support Systems Regulations 1999 (SI 1999/2722, reg 8). Each crew member takes part in at least one abandon-ship drill and one fire drill every month (weekly on Class I, II, II(A) and III). A drill is needed before sailing if the vessel is new to service or has an all-new crew. The regulations exclude Class VI and VI(A).
- Inland waters passenger ships (MSN 1823, Inland Waters Passenger Ship Code). Watertight doors, deadlights, valves and scupper closing mechanisms are opened and closed at least every 7 days, and inspected at least every 7 days by a person appointed by the master (or before a voyage if the vessel has been out of service for more than a week). A bilge alarm with an audible and a separate visual warning at the control position is required in any compartment containing propulsion machinery and any other compartment likely to collect bilge water.
- Workboats and small commercial vessels up to 24m (Workboat Code Edition 3, section 14.11). Practice fire and abandon-ship drills must be carried out regularly and routinely. On vessels over 25 GT they are recorded in the Official Log Book under SI 1999/2722, which sets the monthly drill rule and requires drills within 24 hours of sailing if more than 25% of the crew missed last month's. Recovery-of-persons and liferaft deployment drills must also be regular and recorded, with MOB drills run in daylight, low light and a range of weather. All crew must be familiarised with the lifesaving appliances and emergency procedures. Section 11.3 requires a bilge alarm in any watertight compartment containing propulsion machinery and any other compartment at risk of collecting water, audible at the control position in all conditions.
Under the 1999 Regulations, drills go in the official log, or in records kept on board for 12 months if the vessel has no log book (reg 13). Whatever your code says, a dated record of who took part, what was practised and what you learned is the evidence an auditor will ask for.
Designing a flooding drill that tests the real response
A flooding drill should begin just like a real flood would, with a bilge alarm, a strange tilt, or water where it shouldn't be. Then guide the crew through what to do in the first ten minutes.
A scenario to start from: the engine room bilge alarm sounds mid-trip with passengers aboard.
- Acknowledge and investigate the alarm straight away. Who goes, and who stays at the controls? The MAIB's Opportune flyer says bilge alarms should be investigated promptly.
- Find the source. Seacocks, stern gland, cooling pipework, hull fittings. Crew should know where each is without a torch-lit search.
- Close up. Shut watertight doors, hatches, vents and the valve feeding the leak. Walk through every closure physically during the drill.
- Pump. Start the bilge pumps, including any manual or portable pump, and check they are actually moving water.
- Call early. A PAN PAN or MAYDAY to the coastguard is a decision, not an admission of failure. Rehearse the call and who makes it.
- Prepare the passengers. Calm instructions, lifejackets on, muster at the agreed point, before you know whether you'll need to abandon.
- Decide. Head for shelter or the beach, or prepare to abandon, depending on whether the water is rising.
Make the drill as real as possible. Use an actual alarm test, close the doors and valves yourself, time each step, and change up the scenario: try a different compartment, a night trip, or have the skipper unavailable. Also practise routine checks. The Opportune flyer suggests testing bilge pumps every week and working sea valves every month.
Designing an abandon-ship drill for a small vessel with passengers
On a small passenger boat, abandoning ship usually means two or three crew members have to manage dozens of people who may never have seen your liferaft before. The drill should practise crowd control just as much as handling the equipment.
What to practise:
- The alarm and the announcement. A short, scripted message that tells passengers what to do and where to go.
- Lifejackets on passengers. Where they are stowed, how quickly crew can hand them out, and how to fit child and infant lifejackets.
- Muster and headcount. Verify against the passenger count taken at boarding. Who does the count, and how do they report it?
- Launching the liferaft or buoyant apparatus. Secure the painter, throw or release the raft, inflate it, and board. If you can't inflate a real raft during a drill, walk through each step at the canister and practise at the service station when it's next serviced.
- Vulnerable passengers. People with reduced mobility, children, and anyone who doesn't speak English.
- Distress communication. MAYDAY with position and number on board, EPIRB or PLB activation, and handheld VHF taken into the raft.
- Roles if crew are missing. What happens if the skipper is injured or one deckhand is ashore.
Run table-top drills with the crew too: talk through "what if the engine room floods on the far side of the crossing in a force 6?" Table-tops are quick, cheap and good at showing where the plan relies on one person.
Recording drills and learning from them
A drill record that just says "Fire and abandon ship drill carried out, all crew present" only shows the date. It doesn't show whether anyone can actually do the tasks. A good record should include:
- Date, vessel and scenario (for example, "engine room flooding, mid-crossing, passengers aboard")
- Who took part, and who missed it so they can catch up
- Times for the key steps: alarm to pumps running, alarm to MAYDAY, alarm to all lifejackets on
- What went well and what didn't
- Actions, each with an owner and a date
- A check at the next drill that last time's actions were completed
Under the DSM Code, drill records should be kept in the training manual, and the MCA surveyor will watch a drill during an audit. If your records show the same problem for three drills in a row, it will be flagged. If they show a problem was found, fixed and checked again, that means your system is working.
A real example
One drill I like to use with new mates, especially when we are short-handed, is to pretend I have a heart attack while heading towards a pier. I don't warn them in advance. I watch how they handle the situation, and whether they take charge of the crew and bring the vessel safely alongside.
Often, they bring the boat alongside and think the job is done. Then I point out that the boat isn't tied up, the engines are still running, and no one can get on or off yet. They have to organise the rest of the crew to finish the job. There are always valuable lessons from this drill, and new crew members seem to learn a lot from it.
Lessons from MAIB investigations
Most of the published UK flooding cases with clear drill and alarm findings involve fishing vessels. The lessons carry straight across to workboats and small passenger vessels.
- Argos Georgia (report 19/2026): unstructured emergency response; distress and abandonment delayed; weathertight doors routinely left open; no company systems for flooding, abandonment or distress.
- Ocean Way (report 10/2018): the aft compartment had no bilge alarm or suction. A bulkhead drain valve was routinely left open, and the watertight door and vent flaps were open during the emergency. Fortnightly walk-through drills did not prepare the crew for the scale of the flooding, and there was no flooding checklist.
- Diamond D (report 2/2022): the bilge alarm went unheard because the wheelhouse was unmanned.
- Audacious and Chloe T (report 27/2013): on one vessel the bilge alarm went undetected with the wheelhouse unmanned; on the other the alarms were likely inoperative.
- Opportune (safety flyer, 2026): investigate bilge alarms promptly, keep watertight and weathertight doors closed, test bilge pumps weekly, work sea valves monthly, and have a rehearsed flood response.
Three themes repeat: alarms that don't work or aren't heard, openings left open, and drills that never tested a real flood.
Quick checklist
- You know which drill rules apply to your vessel's class and code
- Bilge alarms are tested, and someone can hear them whenever the vessel is under way
- Watertight doors, hatches and vents are kept closed when they should be, and checked
- Flooding drills start from a realistic trigger and physically close every opening
- Abandon-ship drills include passenger lifejackets, the headcount and the liferaft
- The MAYDAY decision and call are rehearsed, including who makes them
- Drill records include times, lessons and actions with owners
- New crew and new vessels get a drill before the first passenger trip
How Helmsman helps
- Drills written down but not practised. Drill schedules per vessel by type (flooding, fire, abandon ship, MOB), with reminders when one is due or overdue.
- Drill records that prove only a date. Drill records with scenario, participants, timings, lessons and follow-up actions tracked to completion.
- Crew who missed the last drill. Crew records flag anyone who hasn't taken part in each drill type within your set interval.
- Bilge alarms and closures not checked. Vessel inspection checklists for bilge alarm tests, pump checks and watertight closures, with defects raised automatically.
- Liferaft or lifejacket servicing lapsed. Lifesaving equipment records with service and expiry dates.
Helmsman turns your emergency procedures into drills that are scheduled, recorded and followed up, so you can show they are practised, not just written down.
FAQs
How often should a small commercial vessel do abandon-ship drills?
At least monthly for most small commercial vessels. Where the Musters, Training and Decision Support Systems Regulations 1999 apply, each crew member must take part in at least one abandon-ship drill and one fire drill a month, and if more than 25% of the crew haven't done a drill on that vessel in the previous month, drills must be held within 24 hours of leaving port. The Workboat Code requires fire and abandon-ship drills to be carried out regularly and routinely, recorded in the Official Log Book on vessels over 25 GT under those regulations. Domestic passenger vessels under the DSM Code follow the drill programme in their SMS, which in practice means core drills at least monthly.
Do I have to do flooding drills?
The MAIB strongly recommends them. Its Argos Georgia safety flyer says practising closing watertight flaps and ventilation dampers can buy time, and its Opportune flyer calls for a rehearsed flood response.
What should a flooding drill include?
A realistic trigger such as a bilge alarm, finding the source, closing watertight openings, starting pumps, an early PAN PAN or MAYDAY, preparing passengers with lifejackets and a decision on whether to abandon.
What records do I need to keep for drills?
The date, vessel, scenario, who took part, key timings, what went well and badly, and actions with owners. Under the 1999 Regulations, record drills in the official log or keep them on board for 12 months.
Will the MCA ask to see a drill?
Yes. For domestic passenger ships under the DSM Code, MCA surveyors witness the crew carrying out emergency drills on board at audit.
When should I send a MAYDAY?
As soon as there is grave and imminent danger to the vessel or people on board. The MAIB's Argos Georgia findings show the cost of delay. If in doubt, call the coastguard early.
Sources
- MAIB: Argos Georgia report and safety flyer published (25 September 2026)
- MAIB safety flyer: Are your vessel operations approved and practised?
- MAIB safety flyer: Opportune
- Merchant Shipping (Musters, Training and Decision Support Systems) Regulations 1999, reg 8 and reg 13
- MGN 536 (M) Amendment 5: Safety management code for domestic passenger ships
- MSIS 29: Domestic Safety Management Code
- MSN 1823 (M) Edition 2 Amendment 1: Inland Waters Passenger Ship Code
- The Workboat Code Edition 3
- MAIB reports linked in the lessons table above
Helmsman runs this six-stage process for you — capture to close-out, with the records joined up so they survive an audit.
Join the waitlistAbout this guide. Written by John Wilmans, a working skipper who has been through a domestic safety management audit from the side of the operator being audited.Reviewed by John Wilmans on 13 October 2026.
This guide is general information, not legal advice, and it describes United Kingdom (MCA), domestic passenger vessels, Workboat Code Edition 3, DSM Code. Requirements differ between flag states and administrations — always confirm with your own flag state or administration. Spotted something wrong?Tell me and I'll correct it.